Toronto's 2025 Expiration Date and Alleged 'Shitty Engineering': The Dirty Truth About BYD Buses
Toronto electric bus projects face scrutiny over documented reliability failures, specifically the decommissioning of units planned for elimination by 2025. These issues mirror past rollouts, including negative case comparisons drawn with Albuquerque failures.
Commenters are split between two sides. Some, like dgriffith, argue BYD has improved significantly over nine years. Others hammer back, with SaveTheTuaHawk asserting that the Ontario failures stem from 'shitty engineering' and pointing to legal settlements, like the May 2019 lawsuit, where cities allegedly paid nothing for faulty hardware. Steve also grounded the debate by linking current testing to past breakdowns in places like Albuquerque.
The raw consensus leans heavily toward skepticism. The historical record, including explicit decommissioning timelines and legal wrangling over faulty units, suggests the market narrative of unquestioned reliability is unsupported. The fault line is clear: past operational failures outweigh current claims of technological leadership.
Key Points
BYD buses in Toronto are slated for decommissioning by 2025 due to reliability concerns.
SaveTheTuaHawk repeatedly cited this specific endpoint as evidence of systemic failure, regardless of current manufacturer claims.
Past international failures, specifically Albuquerque, set a bad precedent for current technology deployments.
Steve directly compared current testing rollouts to the known failures experienced in Albuquerque, suggesting repeatability.
Legal records show instances where cities settled claims with BYD without paying for faulty equipment.
SaveTheTuaHawk brought up the May 2019 settlement, framing it as financial exoneration from faulty hardware.
Despite historical failures, BYD is positioned as a leading manufacturer with massive technological progress.
dgriffith argued for this narrative, scoring points for BYD's alleged nine-year technological ascent.
The core critique of BYD's vehicles rests on accusations of fundamental engineering failure.
SaveTheTuaHawk stated that the Ontario failure was attributable to 'shitty engineering,' dismissing general market praise.
Source Discussions (5)
This report was synthesized from the following Lemmy discussions, ranked by community score.