Termux vs. PostmarketOS: Why Running Desktop Linux on Android is a Technical Battle, Not a Quick Fix
Achieving a true, modern desktop Linux setup on Android requires heavy lifting via complex middleware like Termux/proot-distro or specialized builds like PostmarketOS (pmOS).
The divide separates the casual tester from the dedicated tinkerer. Canuck on android advises beginners to stick to app wrappers like Andronix for low-risk testing. Meanwhile, pelya confirms complex environments are possible through manual package management in Termux. The heavy artillery comes from balsoft, citing pmOS and Mobian for advanced users, while 1peter10 slams the roadblock: stable VoLTE calling remains unreliable regardless of the ROM. Beyond corrected a deep misconception, noting Android already shares the Linux kernel structure.
The consensus isn't that it's impossible, but that it's a layered compromise. While the underlying OS is Linux (beyond), the practical reality for daily use is constrained by carrier dependencies, specifically VoIP reliability. Beginners have wrappers; experts require extensive, brittle builds.
Key Points
App wrappers are the safest entry point for beginners.
Canuck on android strongly recommends Andronix or UserLAnd to avoid flashing full operating systems.
Complex shell environments are demonstrably achievable.
pelya confirmed Termux functions as a wrapper allowing manual package installation via Debian apt.
Full OS replacement is viable but requires extreme effort.
balsoft presented PostmarketOS (pmOS) and Mobian as viable, yet difficult options for advanced users.
VoLTE stability kills the dream of reliable daily use.
1peter10 noted that reliable VoLTE functionality is dependent on the specific carrier configuration, not just the ROM.
Running Linux on Android is mischaracterized as virtualization.
beyond pointed out that Android is built on the Linux kernel, making it more an interaction with the underlying layer than a VM.
Source Discussions (4)
This report was synthesized from the following Lemmy discussions, ranked by community score.