Systemd Adds Birth Date Field as Age Verification Laws Spread
Systemd v261-rc1 introduced an optional birth date field, sparking debate over its connection to age verification laws in California, Colorado, and Brazil. The change has been interpreted as a compliance measure, though its necessity remains contested.
Commenters split sharply. TheMadBeagle argues the field is preparation for mandatory age verification laws, while excel dismisses it as a 'total nothingburger'. Others, like girsaysdoom, note the laws are preventative and not yet enforced. FauxLiving points out the GECOS field in /etc/passwd has long stored user data, framing the birth date field as a natural extension. Meanwhile, amju_wolf sees it as harmless and useful for parental controls, while LostWanderer warns it could normalize data collection.
The community consensus leans toward viewing the birth date field as a compliance tool, though concerns about surveillance and data normalization persist. The debate highlights a divide between those who see it as a minor feature and those who fear it could lead to broader data collection mandates.
Key Points
#1The birth date field is seen as a response to age verification laws in California, Colorado, and Brazil.
TheMadBeagle and others argue it's preparation for mandatory laws, while excel and mlfh dismiss it as a minor or non-significant change.
#2The GECOS field in /etc/passwd has long been used for storing user information.
FauxLiving highlights this, suggesting the birth date field is not a radical change but an extension of existing practices.
#3The field is optional, but its potential for compliance and surveillance is debated.
girsaysdoom notes the laws are preventative, while LostWanderer warns of normalization of data collection.
#4Some users see the field as harmless and useful for specific purposes.
amju_wolf argues it's useful for parental controls, while DarkMetatron defends Systemd despite the controversy.
Source Discussions (3)
This report was synthesized from the following Lemmy discussions, ranked by community score.