Synthwave Scores Under Fire: Fans Divide Over Genre Purity vs. Cosmic Scope
The discussion centers on curating a high-stakes musical soundtrack for immersive science fiction gaming experiences, targeting moods from general gameplay to cosmic horror, drawing on artists like GUNSHIP and Timecop1983.
The conversation splits sharply on genre boundaries. Some insist the music must stick to classic, dreamy synthwave. Others charge the playlist for completely missing heavy, modern 'Dark Synth' acts such as Carpenter Brut or Perturbator. Meanwhile, some users, like 'wfh', question the inclusion of pre-synthwave acts like John Carpenter and Tangerine Dream, calling them too much 'OG 80'. 'DirigibleProtein' even questioned the collection's authenticity, suggesting AI generation.
The weight of opinion shows acceptance of the collection's *aim*—epic sci-fi scoring—but major fault lines exist regarding genre boundaries. While 'unknownguyfromnowher' defended the inclusion of older, thematic acts like Vangelis, the opposition demands more modern, hard-edged electronic music.
Key Points
The playlist features legitimate, high-quality artists like GUNSHIP and Timecop1983.
essteeyou noted the inclusion of recognizable artists, including Mac Quail.
The music is too soft and lacks heavy, modern synth acts.
wfh criticized the omission of genres and acts like Carpenter Brut or Perturbator.
The inclusion of pre-synthwave classics dilutes the aesthetic.
wfh questioned John Carpenter and Tangerine Dream because they predated the core genre.
The music collection's origin is questioned.
DirigibleProtein explicitly raised concerns about whether the content was AI-generated.
Older artists are included for thematic fit, not strict style.
unknownguyfromnowher argued that artists like Vangelis fit 'wonderfully' thematically, regardless of style.
Source Discussions (3)
This report was synthesized from the following Lemmy discussions, ranked by community score.