NHS Slammed: Is Palantir Overreach or Necessary Tech Overlord? Users Flag Spyware Concerns and Corporate Smoke and Mirrors
Palantir software is being mandated across the NHS, with reports showing over 123 of 205 hospital trusts have already implemented the system. This rollout centers on deploying advanced, large AI systems across critical care infrastructure.
The resistance is sharp. Critics brand the technology rollout as 'smoke and mirrors,' citing jballs' take that the recent demonstrations were superficial. Others blast Palantir for its surveillance history, calling it an 'original CCTV spy' system, as noted by Bloomcole. Conversely, some acknowledge the scope of adoption, like FundMECFS pointing to the wide-scale implementation across the trusts.
The overwhelming sentiment points to deep suspicion. Commenters reject the perceived necessity, focusing instead on data privacy risks and corporate overreach. The fault lines run between frontline staff resisting control and management pushing systems through regardless of operational benefit.
Key Points
Palantir deployment is concerning due to deep privacy fears and overreach.
The general consensus flags concerns over the mandatory nature of the system and its impact on patient data privacy.
The technology demos are seen as lacking substance.
jballs dismissed the demo as superficial, suggesting it was based on generic prompts rather than real analysis.
The company has a history of questionable data practices.
Bloomcole recalled the NHS previously sharing patient records without explicit consent, citing Eye-dentify as an example.
The system adoption is widespread despite the controversy.
FundMECFS noted the wide-scale adoption, confirming over 123 NHS trusts have implemented the software.
Staff resistance points to systemic management failures.
Evilsandwichman argued that firing staff for criticism ignores the underlying workforce crisis: management needs the staff more than the perceived control.
Source Discussions (4)
This report was synthesized from the following Lemmy discussions, ranked by community score.