GrapheneOS Users Grapple with Backup Nightmare: Syncthing vs. Scripts vs. OpenAndroidBackup
Reliable, 'one-click' backup for modern Android, particularly on GrapheneOS, proves nearly impossible without advanced user intervention.
The debate centers on whether to trust simple apps or wield command-line tools. BearOfaTime demands rooting and champions Syncthing-Fork for its 'granular control' over syncing conditions. Conversely, shreddy_scientist recommends the Open Android Backup Companion for its supposed simplicity. Advanced users like solrize argue for the raw power of rsync over USB via Termux, while Atemu suggests a git-annex abstraction layer via ADB.
The community leans toward the understanding that high-integrity backup demands high complexity. The divide remains sharp: those prioritizing ease-of-use are wary, while technical advocates firmly assert that decentralized tools like Syncthing offer the only truly robust, customizable data replication policies.
Key Points
Rooting and Syncthing-Fork provide superior control for comprehensive backup.
BearOfaTime cited Syncthing-Fork's ability to set different sync conditions (e.g., network-specific syncing) as superior to dedicated apps.
Simple backup apps are insufficient for deep data portability.
The general consensus indicates that 'one-click' solutions fail to meet the requirements of deep, secure data synchronization across modern setups.
Command-line methods (rsync/Termux) offer powerful, if complex, backup routes.
solrize suggested rsync over USB via Termux as a potent, command-line fallback for advanced users.
Open Android Backup Companion is viable for users prioritizing straightforward operation.
shreddy_scientist rated the companion highly as a relatively simple option for GrapheneOS users.
ADB combined with git-annex is an alternative mechanism for selective file extraction.
Atemu detailed this as an effective, though more complex, way to pull specific files beyond manual transfer.
Source Discussions (3)
This report was synthesized from the following Lemmy discussions, ranked by community score.