FromSoftware's Veto Power Stalls Bloodborne: Animated Film vs. Direct Remake Showdown
Sony Pictures is pushing an R-rated animated feature film for Bloodborne, a project involving PlayStation Productions and JackSepticEye. This announcement directly contrasts with past reports confirming FromSoftware's absolute control over the Intellectual Property, leading to the rejection of a potential Bluepoint Games remake.
Commenters are split between accepting the animated film push and siding with the desire for a direct game continuation. 'v4ld1z' cites JackSepticEye's personal enthusiasm for the film. Meanwhile, others express deep skepticism, with 'zikzak025' noting Sony's history of shelving film projects entirely. The core friction revolves around whether the IP will be animated or if FS will allow a direct revival.
The consensus holds that FromSoftware maintains significant veto power over Bloodborne adaptations. The primary fault line pits the current animated film momentum against the enduring desire for a traditional game remake, with the structure of that control remaining the central point of contention.
Key Points
FromSoftware retains veto power over major adaptations.
The community confirms FS controls adaptations, citing evidence that FS rejected Bluepoint Games' pitch, regardless of who is currently pushing the film.
A Sony-backed R-rated animated film is actively being promoted.
'v4ld1z' reports the current effort involving Sony Pictures and Lyrical Animation, driven by JackSepticEye.
Past plans for a direct game remake have been shut down by FromSoftware.
'MoonlitSanguine' notes historical reports showing Bluepoint Games pitches were rejected by FromSoftware.
The narrative complexity of the source material is strong enough for any medium.
'v4ld1z' argues the game lore is rich, pointing to NPC hunters and Old Hunter DLC as proof.
Fans doubt any official project will actually see completion.
'zikzak025' brings the skepticism, reminding everyone of Sony's track record with canceled film projects.
Source Discussions (4)
This report was synthesized from the following Lemmy discussions, ranked by community score.