Digital Foundry's DLSS 5 Pivot: Nvidia's PR Shield or Technical Reality Check?
Digital Foundry's initial coverage of DLSS 5 has drawn sharp criticism for appearing overly favorable and too aligned with NVIDIA's narrative.
The technical limits are heavily contested. Key technical inputs cited include that DLSS 5 supposedly only modifies lighting, as argued by bjoern_tantau, while others point out that NVIDIA itself stated the inputs are limited to the 'rendered frame and motion vectors' (inclementimmigrant). There are accusations of misdirection, with Menschlicher_Fehler dismissing claims that 'the underlying geometry is unchanged' as 'Slop-Vaseline.' Meanwhile, bazell points to the Italian TV broadcast facing a copyright strike as evidence of 'sophisticated trolling.'
Skepticism dominates. Multiple users view the reassessment as damage control, suggesting Digital Foundry functioned as a mouthpiece for NVIDIA initially (Totonator). The division rests squarely on whether the tech is genuinely limited versus whether the coverage was inherently biased from the start.
Key Points
Digital Foundry's initial praise for DLSS 5 was suspect.
Users claim the coverage seemed too close to NVIDIA's talking points, leading to immediate skepticism.
DLSS 5's technical scope is severely limited.
bjoern_tantau asserts the tech 'only modified lighting'; inclementimmigrant cites NVIDIA confirming inputs are limited to 'rendered frame and motion vectors'.
Claims about geometry preservation are dismissed.
Menschlicher_Fehler labels the claim 'the underlying geometry is unchanged' as misleading, suggesting a cover-up.
The debate extends beyond GPUs to IP law.
weirdo_from_space argued that 'The concept of intellectual property is inherently corrupt,' shifting focus away from the core technology.
NVIDIA's PR actions are being scrutinized.
Totonator labels Digital Foundry's prior support as making them appear like a 'mouthpiece for NVIDIA.'
Source Discussions (3)
This report was synthesized from the following Lemmy discussions, ranked by community score.