Copyright Over Your Face: Danish/Dutch Deepfake Fight Sparks Battle Over Digital Identity Lawsuit
Nations are proposing giving citizens copyright over their own faces and voices as a shield against deepfakes, potentially using digital signatures to verify genuine content.
Commenters are split on function versus fiction. Some users argue the mechanism is weak, demanding answers like, "How is this supposed to work? What about identical twins? What about people who look alike?" Others see a legal weapon: "You probably claim copyright infringement if a shady cam face recognition service takes your image. And they'd have to remove it." The core debate pits legal enforcement against fundamental rights, with some voicing fears of governmental overreach, citing parallels to "SovCit theory."
The practical focus settles on establishing a verifiable standard. The consensus points toward using this legal hook to challenge profit-making data brokers, rather than fearing an unmanageable flood of personal lawsuits. The weakness remains biological replication and the shadow of free speech protections, particularly parody.
Key Points
#1The proposed mechanism's failure to account for biological reality.
Notfromhere questioned the law's viability regarding identical twins or highly similar-looking individuals.
#2The potential utility against commercial data theft.
BCsven noted the law's strength in forcing removal from 'agencies selling your face data, since they are profiting off of copyrighted "works"'.
#3The primary goal is system standardization, not litigation chaos.
Cygnus stated the goal is establishing a standard where content lacking a verifiable signature is presumed fake.
#4The measure forces a 'David against Goliath' legal battle.
Obando (cited in Dutch MP thread) viewed taking action against tech giants as an inevitable, massive legal fight.
#5The legal action is clearest when impersonation is direct.
hitmyspot suggested law application is clearest when someone is actively impersonated.
Source Discussions (3)
This report was synthesized from the following Lemmy discussions, ranked by community score.